Build, Buy, or Integrate? How to Know When to Build Custom Software

Build, Buy, or Integrate? How to Know When to Build Custom Software
Blogs » Build, Buy, or Integrate? How to Know When to Build Custom Software
Table of Contents

Most businesses ask whether to build or buy software before they know what problem they’re trying to solve. That order is backward. Knowing when to build custom software starts with the pain point, not the technology, and often the right first move is connecting the tools you already have rather than writing new code.

That’s the approach Ghazenfer Mansoor, founder and CEO of Technology Rivers, laid out in a conversation with Adi Klevit on the Systems Simplified podcast. A software engineer since the late 1990s, he has worked with early-stage startups, government agencies like Veterans Affairs and the EPA, and corporate teams, and he founded Technology Rivers in 2015. Below is how he thinks about when custom software isn’t worth it, when it pays off, and how to build it without taking on unnecessary risk.

You May Not Need Custom Software. You May Need Better Integrations.

Start with what you have. You don’t want to build something that already exists, so use existing tools until they stop meeting your needs.

In fact, custom software vs. off-the-shelf tools may be the wrong comparison to start with, and it often comes up too early to tell you when to build custom software. The better starting point is the specific problem and pain point. Sometimes existing software, plus a few integrations, solves it.

Using an existing tool first also helps you figure out what you actually need. Many business owners haven’t built a product before, and requirements are rarely clear at the start. Working with something real is how you get that clarity.

Here’s how integration can replace a full build. Project management tools like monday.com and Jira have APIs, which let other software pull data out of them. Say you want a customer dashboard that pulls data from 20 different places. Instead of building a whole new system, you build one tool that pulls the data in and pushes it to the right places.

From there, you build one piece at a time:

  • Integrate the tools you already use.
  • When you hit one specific problem integration can’t solve, build just that piece.
  • Repeat as new gaps show up.

Building a large, complicated system all at once carries a real risk: it can be obsolete by the time you finish, because tools and technology change so quickly. Many projects work well with integration alone.

If integration can’t close the gap, building is the next option, but count the cost first.

Don’t Spend Two Months Building What an Existing Tool Already Does

Custom software has real downsides, and cost is the biggest one. Development isn’t easy, it’s expensive, and the cost adds up gradually. There’s also the risk of building in the wrong direction. If you don’t know how to build a product, you can end up paying for features you rarely use. Getting it right takes product knowledge and the right people.

Developers can make this worse, simply because they enjoy the work. Ask for a specialized calendar, and as long as it’s technically possible, a developer will happily build it. That might take two months. But if an existing approach covers 80% of what you need, putting that time and money elsewhere may deliver a better return.

 

“The key part for us is solving the problem. It’s not just about building because developers love to build.”

 

So part of knowing when to build custom software is being honest about the gaps. If an existing tool handles everything except one thing, do you really need a custom build for that one thing? It depends on your goal. Sometimes outside software makes sense on cost alone, even if it doesn’t do everything. When you weigh off-the-shelf vs. custom software, the bottom line is ROI.

So when does building pay off? Often, it comes down to what the software is worth to your business.

Can Technology 10X Your Service Business?

Most service businesses sell at low valuations. In Ghazenfer’s experience, they typically trade at 1X to 3X EBITDA, meaning a buyer pays one to three times the company’s yearly operating profit. A big reason is that there’s no technology inside them. Add defensible intellectual property (IP), and that multiple can climb to 15X, 20X, or even 30X, because AI and technology bring efficiency and let the business grow well beyond what headcount alone allows.

That doesn’t mean you need to build everything yourself. Tools already exist for most jobs. The better question is what will give your business an advantage. Your goal shapes the answer:

  • Solving your own problem. You want a tool that fixes a workflow inside your company.
  • Solving it for others, too. You want to fix your own problem and then turn the solution into a product other companies can use.

The second goal is how Ghazenfer approached his own recruitment software startup. Existing recruiting tools were available, but they weren’t right for certain types of companies. Some added complications, and some got too expensive.

Not sure whether your next step is an integration or a custom build? Talk it through with the Technology Rivers team.

Own Your Software. Own the IP. Control What Comes Next.

The biggest advantage when you custom build software is the asset itself. You own the technology, and that raises the value of your business. The second advantage is control: you decide which features get built, based on what you need and what your customers ask for.

The clearest signal of when to build custom software is a workflow that keeps costing you. Look for:

  • Jobs that take a lot of people. If a task needs a large team to get done, that’s a cost you can reduce.
  • Work you repeat again and again. Anything you do over and over in an expensive way is costing you every time, and that’s where workflow and process automation pays off.
  • Not the rare stuff. A task you handle once a year or every other year may not be worth automating, even if it’s costly when it happens.

Control matters because off-the-shelf vendors set their own priorities. Technology Rivers runs into this with the tools it uses, too. A request goes in, and the answer comes back: it’s a great feature, but it’s not in the product because not every customer is asking for it. When you own the software, that decision is yours.

In some industries, though, owning your software isn’t just an advantage. It’s the only way to meet the rules you operate under.

Why Generic Software Fails Complex Healthcare Workflows

Healthcare is where off-the-shelf tools most often fall short. Wherever there are compliance requirements, you have to keep a lot of paperwork and detailed records, and patient data adds HIPAA on top of that.

Medicaid is a good example. Its billing rules are complicated, the way services are used is closely tracked, and audits are frequent. If the workflow is wrong, you don’t get paid. Gaps like these are a big part of why healthcare software projects fail.

Existing tools usually do broader things. Some are HIPAA compliant, but often only from their own perspective, which may mean little more than encrypting stored data. Compliance for a real healthcare operation goes well beyond encryption or data storage.

Beyond HIPAA: Building Software for Real Healthcare Workflows

To solve those compliance problems for a company that works with Medicaid, Technology Rivers built a custom tool that covers the whole workflow, from onboarding a customer to getting paid or finishing work with them. It includes:

  • Log notes
  • Treatment plans
  • Auditing

Remote patient monitoring is another case where a custom build pays off. In the remote patient monitoring platform Technology Rivers built, patients use cellular devices like scales and blood pressure monitors, and every reading is pushed to the cloud. Doctors can then review the data and bill for that review, which increases their reimbursement and gives providers a new revenue stream.

When to Build Custom Software: The Bottom Line

The custom software vs. off-the-shelf decision comes down to one step: define the problem before you decide how to solve it. That’s what tells you when to build custom software, when to integrate, and when to keep using what you have. Skip that step, and you risk building things you don’t need, paying for features nobody uses, or ending up with a system that’s outdated before it launches.

Before you build, check:

  • What specific pain point are you solving?
  • Have you used an existing tool long enough to know your real requirements?
  • Can an integration solve the problem instead of a full build?
  • Would building it return more than an existing tool that covers 80% of the need?
  • Is the workflow repeated often enough, at enough cost, to justify automating it?
  • Would owning the software create IP that adds value to your business?
  • In healthcare, does your compliance need go beyond what the vendor’s version of “HIPAA compliant” covers?

That’s how Technology Rivers works with every client: start with the specific problem, then decide whether an existing tool, an integration, or a custom build solves it.

If your current tools cover most of what you need, see how Technology Rivers approaches software integrations before you commit to a full build.

Consultation invitation with call-to-action

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Stay in the know about the latest technology tips & tricks

Learn why software projects fail and how to get back on track

In this eBook, you'll learn what it takes to get back on track with app development when something goes wrong so that your next project runs smoothly without any hitches or setbacks.

Sign up to download the FREE eBook!

Do you have a software app idea but don’t know if...

Technology Rivers can help you determine what’s possible for your project

Contact Us

Interested in working with Technology Rivers? Tell us about your project today to get started! If you prefer, you can email us at [email protected] or call 703.444.0505.